The World of Symphony 5 Beethoven: Symphony No. 5 / Symphony No. 6 is a captivating CD that offers a mix of outstanding and mediocre performances, as per customer feedback. The CD features Kurt Sanderling’s bold and aggressive rendition of Beethoven’s 5th Symphony, praised for its beautiful sound and substantial nature. On the other hand, Herbert Kegel’s interpretation of Beethoven’s 6th Symphony is described as well-played but somewhat fast for some listeners’ tastes.
One of the standout features of this CD is Kurt Sanderling’s remarkable performance of Beethoven’s 5th Symphony. The recording is lauded for its propulsive and movingly lyrical nature, sustained majesty, and weight. The orchestral playing and clear recording contribute to the heft and power projected, making it a standout rendition in the collection of many listeners.
However, some customers expressed disappointment with Sanderling’s performance, finding it glib and superficial, lacking the weight and flight expected from such a renowned piece. Additionally, Kegel’s rendition of Beethoven’s 6th Symphony, while well-played, was deemed dull and mediocre by some, although others appreciated its ability to find an ideal tempo throughout.
Pros:
- Bold and aggressive rendition of Beethoven’s 5th Symphony by Kurt Sanderling
- Clear recording and powerful orchestral playing
- Well-played interpretation of Beethoven’s 6th Symphony by Herbert Kegel
Cons:
- Sanderling’s performance may be perceived as glib and superficial by some listeners
- Kegel’s rendition of Beethoven’s 6th Symphony was found dull and mediocre by certain customers
In conclusion, the World of Symphony 5 Beethoven: Symphony No. 5 / Symphony No. 6 CD offers a mix of exceptional and average performances of Beethoven’s renowned symphonies. While Sanderling’s rendition of the 5th Symphony stands out for its power and lyrical nature, some listeners may find it lacking. Similarly, Kegel’s interpretation of the 6th Symphony, while well-played, may not resonate with all listeners. Overall, the CD presents an intriguing blend of performances, making it a worthwhile addition to any classical music collection.
Leave a Reply